Elkay D233194 Replacement Guide: 33 × 19 Sink, Four Holes and Shallow Bowls

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Purchases through our links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.

The Elkay Dayton D233194 is worth considering for a budget-conscious, like-for-like kitchen refresh when you need a 33 × 19-inch drop-in double sink with four faucet holes. The critical number is 19 inches front to back. Buying any sink labeled “33 inch” is not enough to establish that it will cover your old countertop opening.

This guide separates the replacement measurements from bowl depth and faucet layout. We checked Elkay’s D23319 family specifications, the D233194 model page and the selected US Amazon four-hole variant on September 17, 2026. It is a document-based buying guide, not an installation or sound test.

Start with the opening you actually have

Read “33 × 19 × 6-7/16 inches” as outside left-to-right width, outside front-to-back dimension and overall sink height. The 19-inch figure is not the depth of the bowls. Elkay lists each bowl as 14 × 14 inches with a 6-5/16-inch bowl depth, and a 36-inch minimum cabinet width for this model.

A common replacement mistake is confusing an old 33 × 22-inch sink with a 33 × 19-inch sink. They share one advertised dimension and differ by three inches in the other. That does not mean the smaller one can safely bridge the old cutout. It also does not establish the exact cutout difference, since rim widths and corner shapes may differ.

Before ordering, ask the installer to record the existing opening’s width, front-to-back span, corner shape and available rim-bearing area. A tape measure laid over the visible sink rim cannot reveal all of that. When the old sink is still in place, its model number or original cutout drawing can help establish the starting point.

Photograph the underside too. Include mounting clips, the cabinet front rail, drain pipes and faucet connections. These pictures are useful for a quote; they do not replace direct measurements. Have the installer check the new template against the old opening before promising a simple swap.

Give all four faucet holes a job

The final “4” in the selected D233194 model corresponds to the four-hole version shown on its model page. Do not let an online size selector switch you to a different hole pattern while comparing prices. Check the full model number, selected hole count and order summary together.

Sketch your planned layout before buying the faucet. A faucet with multiple mounting points, a separate sprayer, a soap dispenser and an air-gap fitting can compete for the same deck space. Whether an air gap is required depends on the installation and local requirements; have the plumber include it in the plan instead of leaving it as a surprise.

• Reusing a faucet: confirm its mounting pattern, deck plate, connection condition and hose reach. Age alone does not establish whether reuse is economical.
• Choosing a single-hole faucet: confirm how every unused opening will be covered. A decorative plate is only useful when its dimensions and supported mounting pattern match.
• Adding a dispenser: check the refill method and room for the bottle underneath. A crowded cabinet may make an attractive accessory inconvenient.
• Keeping a side sprayer: check the hose’s travel below the sink. It should not snag on the drain or stored cleaning supplies.

The goal is a complete layout with no unexplained hole. This is a separate decision from whether you prefer one basin or two.

A shallow double sink has a particular audience

The D233194’s two smaller, shallower bowls can suit a familiar wash-and-rinse routine. They are less compelling if your main task is soaking a tall stockpot or lowering a broad baking sheet flat into the basin. A sink that occupies 33 inches of counter does not provide a 33-inch-wide uninterrupted washing area.

Test the intended workflow with the objects you own. Measure a pot across its handles. Compare the rim of a roasting tray, not just the cooking surface. Think about where a second large item waits while the first is being washed. If you mostly use a dishwasher and hand-wash only oversize cookware, a divider may consume precisely the space you value most.

A shallower bowl changes reach and splash containment, but comfort is individual. Counter height, your posture and the faucet stream all matter. We would not label this an ergonomic solution from bowl depth alone. Likewise, the manufacturer’s accessibility classification does not make every countertop, cabinet or installed plumbing arrangement compliant.

Use our single versus double-bowl decision guide if the basic layout is still open. If your countertop is staying, solve the opening constraint first; a theoretically nicer bowl is not useful if the project needs unbudgeted fabrication.

Understand the value trade-off: 22 gauge and basic damping

Elkay lists 22-gauge stainless steel and sound-deadening pads on the bottom only. Those are meaningful specifications for a value-focused replacement. They do not justify a claim that it will sound or feel like a heavier sink with broader damping coverage.

We have not measured its noise or resistance to dents. Do not substitute an online star average for those tests. If a heavy, solid feel or lower dish noise is your highest priority, compare construction and installed support before ordering. Our stainless-steel gauge guide explains why the gauge number is only part of the decision; this Elkay’s specified 22 gauge is a different thickness again.

Price the job as a replacement project

Ask for the quote before discarding the old sink or arranging countertop work. A low product price can be a good starting point, but it should not conceal a layout mismatch. Keep the delivered sink, packaging and documentation available for inspection until the installer confirms the fit.

The drain openings are listed as 3½ inches. That is not a guarantee that every disposal, flange or old drain assembly can be reused. The connection stack and pipe elevations still need checking. Our sink and disposal clearance guide helps organize those measurements.

Common questions

Can it replace a 33 × 22-inch sink?

Not on that description alone. The D233194 has a smaller outside front-to-back dimension. Verify the existing cutout and template; do not assume matching widths make it compatible.

Can I turn the four-hole version into a one-hole appearance?

A compatible faucet plate and appropriate covers may help, but the remaining openings still exist. Verify the actual hardware layout rather than expecting the sink itself to change.

Is it a good choice for large cookware?

Only if the actual cookware works with two 14 × 14-inch bowls and the divider. For routine large-pan washing, an uninterrupted basin may be the more useful upgrade.

Our recommendation

Choose the D233194 when keeping a compatible older opening, controlling project cost and retaining two separate bowls matter more than deep-basin capacity or premium construction. If the opening or faucet layout is uncertain, get those checked first. A correct modest replacement is a better purchase than a bargain that starts a countertop rebuild.

Research notes: Elkay D233194 model specifications, D23319 family specification sheet revision January 14, 2026, and the selected US four-hole listing. Checked September 17, 2026. No cutout size, universal fit, sound-test result or installation-compliance guarantee is claimed.

For a smaller single-bowl replacement, see the Elkay D125223 25 × 22-inch fit guide. Its 30-inch minimum cabinet, three-hole deck and separate cutout checks differ from this 33 × 19-inch model.